Examine individual changes

'@@ -1,52 +1,59 @@ {{Proposal page -|name = Practitioners -|user = GA Kevin -|key = <!-- The key of the proposed new tag, if relevant --> -|value = <!-- The value of the proposed new tag, if relevant --> -|type = <!-- node, way, area, relation --> -|definition = <!-- A short, clear definition of the feature or property which the new tag represents --> -|appearance = <!-- A possible rendering, if relevant - optional --> -|status = Draft -|draftStartDate = 2025-01-09 -|rfcStartDate = <!-- Date the RFC email is sent to the Tagging list: YYYY-MM-DD --> -|voteStartDate = <!-- Date voting will start: at least 2 weeks after RFC, YYY-MM-DD format --> -|voteEndDate = <!-- Date voting will end: at least 2 weeks after start of voting, YYY-MM-DD format --> +| name = Practitioners +| user = GA Kevin +| key = practitioners +| type = {{IconNode}} {{IconWay}} {{IconArea}} {{IconRelation}} +| definition = A list of practitioners practicing in a given location. +| appearance = hidden +| status = Proposed +| draftStartDate = 2025-01-09 +| rfcStartDate = 2025-01-09 +| voteStartDate = 2025-02-01 +| voteEndDate = 2025-03-01 +| tagging = practitioners=* }} - - ==Proposal== -<!-- A short statement of what you propose, including a list of what tag(s) are being proposed to be added, changed, or deprecated --> - -<!-- Which Database Elements (nodes, ways, areas, relations) each of the tags can be used on could be included here or under the Tagging heading, or both. --> - +Add a key practitioners=* to list the practitioners in a given location.<br /> ==Rationale== -<!-- Explanation of why the proposal is needed, and why you chose the specific key and value of the tag. Compare with similar tags or previous proposals, if relevant. Consider significance and potential uses of the data.--> +Many professional locations list publicly the practitioners that practice within a location. Most notably medical, legal, and accountant firms are sometimes referred to more by the practitioner located within a location than the formal name of the building or office itself. This information can be a valuable addition to the data within OSM by adding the ability to query and filter by practitioner name as well as the building or office name. Additionally, further use can be used by querying [[Key:healthcare:speciality]] or [[Key:craft]] to display a list of all practitioners in a given predefined area or operator. This tag is intended to be used to signify a list of one or more individuals, all of whom are operating in one location, all of whom are practicing the same speciality. -<!-- Keep the tag short while still being logical and descriptive enough to need little explanation. Avoid tag names which might cause confusion with a different tag. British English terms are preferred, when possible --> +'''Special care should be taken when listing practitioners to only list those names which are publicly made available, such as those listed on a sign or advertisement.''' -==Tagging== -<!-- -A table, list, or set of subheadings explaining each tag: -* Definition of the meaning of the tag and how it should be used -* Elements tagged: nodes, ways, areas or relations? [if a feature is smaller than 5m by 5m it would usually be mapped only as a node] -* Comparison with current tagging schemes (if applicable) -* Additional tags used in combination (including existing tags) -* When other tags should be used instead. ---> +== Potential Issues == +There exists several potential issues with a single `practitioners:*` tag. -==Examples== -<!-- Examples of what elements should be tagged: real-world images, openstreetmap.org screenshots, links to OpenStreetMap elements that use the proposed tagging. --> +# Length limit and readability, if many practitioners operate in the same location, the value of this tag can theoretically get very large. +# Duplication if a practitioner has a "home office" but also "visiting offices" such as a doctor with a primary office, and is also a frequent practitioner at the local hospital. +# Differing information within a location. Such as when a pair of lawyers share a office, staff, and other attributes, but each has their own email. -==Rendering== -<!-- Optional rendering suggestion, if relevant --> -==Features/Pages affected== -<!-- List of wiki pages that would be edited if the proposal is approved --> +Nevertheless, the practitioners tag potential benefit far exceeds the challenges of how to mitigate these potential issues and further refinement can be made throughout the proposal process. +== Tagging == +{| class="wikitable" +|+ +!Tag +!Tagged On +!Description +!Example +|- +|practitioners=* +|{{IconNode}} {{IconWay}} {{IconArea}} {{IconRelation}} +|A list of individuals and appropriate titles that practice at a given location. +|practitioners=Jane Doe, MD; John Doe, CNA +|- +|practitioners:primary=* +|{{IconNode}} {{IconWay}} {{IconArea}} {{IconRelation}} +|A list of the primary or senior practitioners and appropriate titles that practice at a given location. +|practitioners:primary=Jane Doe, MD +|- +|practitioners:support=* +|{{IconNode}} {{IconWay}} {{IconArea}} {{IconRelation}} +|A list of support practitioners and appropriate titles that practice at a given location. +|practitioners:primary=Jane Doe, MD +practitioners:support=John Doe, CNA +|} ==External discussions== -<!-- Links to mailing lists, other forums where this proposal has been discussed... --> ==Comments== -<!-- There must be at least 2 weeks set aside for comment on the proposal. Do not go to a vote without addressing the comments and fixing any problems with the proposal. The wiki talk page is used for comments, it is linked from the proposal page for those unfamiliar with wikis. --> - Please comment on the [[{{TALKPAGENAME}}|discussion page]]. '